Police Officer Jailed 4 Years For Refusing To Decrypt Hard Drives


Police officer jailed 4 years for refusing to decrypt hard drives.

A Philadelphia man has been freed after a federal appeals court ruled that his continued detention was violating federal law.

Francis Rawls, a former police officer, had been in jail since 2015, when a federal judge held him in contempt for failing to decrypt two hard drives taken from his home.

Police officer jailed 4 years for refusing to decrypt harddrives.

The government 'believes', they contain child pornography.

After losing that appeal, Rawls raised another challenge: the federal statute that allows judges to hold witnesses in contempt for refusing to testify, passed in 1970, states that:

"in no event shall such confinement exceed eighteen months."

The government argued that this provision didn't apply to Rawls because he was a suspect, not a witness.

Also, the rule applies to a "proceeding before or ancillary to any court or grand jury."

But because the government hadn't formally charged Rawls with a crime, the government argued, there was no court proceeding under way.

Last week, a three-judge panel of the 3rd Circuit rejected this argument in a 2-1 vote.

The court's two-judge majority held that Congress had intended for the 18-month limitation to apply broadly to any legal proceeding, not just a formal trial.

And while Rawls was a suspect in the case, he was also a witness.

The practical result is that, at least in federal court, someone can 'only' be imprisoned for 18 months for refusing to open an encrypted device.

The government says it has other evidence 'suggesting' that Rawls possessed child pornography, "so prosecutors may be able to piece together enough evidence to convict him, even without access to his encrypted hard drives," the report adds.

"One of the two judges who formed the 3rd Circuit's majority urged the trial court judge to consider the four years of imprisonment Rawls has already served if he eventually has to sentence Rawls after a child pornography conviction."

Featured Sponsors

Games For Linux

Windows has always been the preferred platform for gaming, but after STEAM's interest in Linux more game developers are making their games natively available for Linux.


All information on this website is published in good faith and for general educational purposes and for use in safe testing environments only. While linuxexperten.com strives to make the information on this site as accurate as possible, linuxexperten.com does not warrant its completeness, reliability and accuracy.

We are not responsible for any losses or damages associated with the use of our website. While we strive to provide only links to useful websites, we have no control over the content of these sites and links to other sites do not constitute a recommendation for all content contained on these websites.


Site Information

This is a professional review site that receives compensation from the companies whose products reviewed. Each service or product are thoroughly tested and given high marks if considered to be the very best. Independently owned and the opinions expressed here are no one elses.